Jump to main content

Publication : Puzzles of Indian Commodity Production

Capitalist Exploitation and Heterogeneity of Rural and Informal Sectors in the Indian Economy

Key facts

Series
Online Publication
Author
Jakob Graf,
Published
February 2015
Ordering advice
Only available online

Details

While the old capitalist countries have to contend with low growth rates, eyes turn to countries like India. High economic growth and corporate profit margins can be observed, enjoyed and expected. Some areas like the IT-sector or the pharma industry are of special interest. But in terms of numbers of employees this capitalist dynamic and accumulation is limited to a small part of the Indian economy. The vast majority of Indians is not part of the highly value adding capitalist economy. 70% of the population are living in rural areas, where subsistence production, public or self-employment is predominant.Also in cities, large capitalist industries are rare compared to the bulk of small producers.

There are various types of modes of production to be found in the different areas of the Indian economy. Notwithstanding the small share of capitalist production, I claim that the capitalist relations of commodity circulation and accumulation clearly dominate the economy on a macroeconomic level. This implies a capitalist state and rule of law. More and more neoliberal policies are directed towards an integration of the Indian economies into the global division of labour, growth of selected industries and characterised by a neglect of agriculture and the various types of excluded economies of the thirdtypo3/#_ftn1.

This development is not leading to notable job creation and its growing wealth does not benefit the majority of the Indian population. Some authors define different sub-economies in post-colonial countries like India. Rajesh Bhattacharya and Kalyan Sanyal for example speak of an accumulation economy, on the one hand, and a need economy, on the other hand. The former is organised around the logic of accumulation of surplus, whereas the latter is aiming at provisioning sufficient goods or income for subsistence (Bhattacharya/Sanyal 2011). The coexistence of the various types of societies and modes of productions is not at all without conflicts – especially conflicts over the control of land.

[More in the PDF]

More on this theme

From the Green Deal to a War Deal?

: Analysis 02.12.2025

The West used to promote a corporate-led energy transition, but has now pivoted to military spending

UN Treaty: Corporate Lobbying vs. Global Justice

: Online Publication 11/2025

The UN negotiations on transnational corporations and other business enterprises with respect to…

Heating Should Never Be a Luxury

: Analysis 10.12.2025

The German government’s planned scrapping of the “Heating Act” will fuel social division in the…